Return to Gemcell:
Click here.

Political correctness – has Australia gone mad?

August 28, 2024
Political correctness – has Australia gone mad?

If you’re old enough to remember the days of beer and banter in the workplace, you may be wondering what happened to all the fun. Two words: political correctness!

Smoking at your desk, long lunch breaks, flirting with co-workers and beers before knock-off on Fridays. Ah, the good old days, before political correctness took over the world!

Topless calendars, questionable jokes and coming to work late with a banging hangover. Not quite so good.

Sexual harassment, racist comments, bullying the new kid. Not good at all.

There are some things that shouldn’t be tolerated under any circumstances, but in the modern workplace, do we really need all these rules, regulations and political correctness? Whatever happened to good old common sense?

“In a nutshell, the purpose of having rules that govern workplace behaviour is to create a sense of fairness and belonging,” says workplace mental health expert Mark Butler.

“For most people, feeling that their contribution matters is more important than status. And a laugh is always good for morale. But it’s crucial to understand where to draw the line.”

Treading that line between ensuring fairness at work without creating an atmosphere where no one dares crack a joke can be a headache for the modern employer.

For example, it’s a time-honoured tradition in the trades to have a bit of fun with the junior, the apprentice or the new guy. On the one hand, that might make them feel that they’re a proper part of the team. On the other hand

“It’s worth noting that a lot of millennials and Gen Z haven’t grown up with the teasing and the tall poppy syndrome that earlier generations have experienced, making them even more vulnerable,” says Mark.

“What I often suggest to employers is to think about how they’d feel if their child was being treated in this way. Would they tolerate it? If not, then there’s your answer.”

Will political correctness continue to change the workplace?

So will the workplace become even more politically correct in the future?

For everyone who thinks things have already gone too far, there’s someone else who thinks the regulations haven’t gone far enough. If you’re in the former camp, buckle up.

Those “good old days” could be right now.

The workplace has changed a lot over the past 40 years or so!

Here’s a few things that were considered A-ok a few years ago. Not so much now…

Then: Who remembers the Pirelli calendar girls? Hands up, we even had them in our magazine Electrical Gems, back in the day! Scantily clad women once graced the walls of every office, warehouse and construction site, exploiting the power that naked women have to manipulate men into buying tyres. Among other things.

Now: Pictures of topless women became the focus of one too many compensation claims and even Pirelli stopped featuring bare breasts in 2016. These days, where they still exist, nudie calendars are more likely to feature hunky firemen or CWA ladies with strategically placed cupcakes.

Then: Ashtray on your desk, asking customers if it was OK to smoke in the house (they rarely said no), camaraderie around smoko, going home stinking of smoke.

Now: Designated and unpleasant smoking areas, cigarette breaks frowned upon, doesn’t really matter because you can’t afford it anyway.

Then: Once upon a time it was perfectly acceptable to call your redheaded colleague Bluey, refer to Americans as Seppos, and give someone a Chinese burn. Sledging your workmates came with the turf.

Now: The onus is on bosses to make sure banter is light-hearted and playful rather than using ‘jokes’ to cover up harassment. (Note: Generally the people who complain loudest about this are the worst offenders.)

Then: A couple of schooners in the pub at lunchtime then an early dart, or back to base while the apprentice did a run to the bottle shop for a few more beers and a bag of Samboys if you were lucky.

Now: There’s a legal blood alcohol level in some jobs – including road and rail transport, maritime and mining – that prohibits workers from being affected by any drug, and that includes alcohol. Some companies have policies to test workers, where injury or death is a risk.

Then: Smokos and lunch breaks were cheered by someone telling a ripper they’d heard on the weekend. No offence, mate!

Now: Trying to work out how to repeat a rib-tickler without offending anyone — and giving it up as a bad idea. Well, at least it stops you screwing up the punchline.

Political correctness court cases

Has political correctness gone mad? It seems sometimes common sense prevails.

  • An engineer from Melbourne took his former employer to the Supreme Court of Victoria, claiming that a co-worker was bullying him — by farting on him. The complainant, who was chasing $1.8 million in compensation, told the court that “flatulence was a form of bullying”. He lost the case, with the judge ruling that he was motivated by revenge for his termination.
  • A UK judge dismissed claims by a Japanese professor that she suffered race discrimination when a colleague at London Uni recommended a sushi restaurant to her. The tribunal found that the exchange amounted to “small talk” and that no reasonable person would take offence.
  • A group of British student vets received a complaint from animal rights activists over a calendar image in which they used a sheep to cover their modesty. The British Cattle Veterinary Association came to their defence arguing that the sheep’s involvement was “widely recognised as being safe and pain-free for the animals”. The image was removed, nonetheless.

A sales exec at an Aussie drinks company was sacked for referring to a manager as “Brazilian” when her heritage was in fact Argentine and Italian. The exec was dismissed for making a racial slur. Her appeal for unfair dismissal was upheld by the Fair Work Commission, who condemned her poor grasp of geography but nothing else.

Latest

Business Toolbox: Marketing

Marketing is essential to keep those customers coming in. Here, our experts answer questions posed by electrical contractors just like you. How important are Online Reviews? Rachael Grant, Digital Strategist and Founder at RJE Marketing, says: Reviews are an essential asset for any business, offering numerous benefits that can help build trust (social proofing), enhance [...]<p><a class="btn btn-secondary understrap-read-more-link" href="https://gemcell.com.au/knowledge-and-insights/business-toolbox-marketing/">Read More...<span class="screen-reader-text"> from Business Toolbox: Marketing</span></a></p>

Business Toolbox: Finance

Managing people is a key part of any small business – but it can be one of the most difficult aspects of the job. We put your questions to our experts! How do I price jobs to ensure I’m making a profit and not just covering costs?  Steve Kantor, Fractional CFO with clients in the [...]<p><a class="btn btn-secondary understrap-read-more-link" href="https://gemcell.com.au/knowledge-and-insights/business-toolbox-finance/">Read More...<span class="screen-reader-text"> from Business Toolbox: Finance</span></a></p>

Business Toolbox: HR

Managing people is a key part of any small business – but it can be one of the most difficult aspects of the job. We put your questions to our experts! How important are soft skills, and what training could I arrange for my team? Martha Travis, Founder of Martha Travis People Innovators, says: Firstly, [...]<p><a class="btn btn-secondary understrap-read-more-link" href="https://gemcell.com.au/knowledge-and-insights/business-toolbox-hr/">Read More...<span class="screen-reader-text"> from Business Toolbox: HR</span></a></p>

News


View all

Knowledge and Insights

Business Toolbox: Marketing

Knowledge and Insights

Business Toolbox: Finance

Knowledge and Insights

Business Toolbox: HR

Knowledge and Insights

Business Toolbox: Legal

The Heritage Issue

Out Now

The Heritage Issue

Current Issue

The Heritage Issue

Apr-May 2025

The Heritage Issue

Past Issues

View all
  • The Showtime Issue

    Issue 183

    The Showtime Issue

    OCT - NOV 2024

  • The Bias Issue

    Issue 182

    The Bias Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2024

  • The Distance Issue

    Issue 181

    The Distance Issue

    JUN - JUL 2024

  • The Growth Issue

    Issue 180

    The Growth Issue

    APR - MAY 2024

  • The Workfit Issue

    Issue 179

    The Workfit Issue

    FEB - MARCH 2024

  • The Fire and Water Issue

    Issue 178

    The Fire and Water Issue

    DEC 2023 - JAN 2024

  • The Multi-Res Issue

    Issue 177

    The Multi-Res Issue

    OCT - NOV 2023

  • The Cost of Living Issue

    Issue 176

    The Cost of Living Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2023

  • The Winter Issue

    Issue 175

    The Winter Issue

    JUN - JUL 2023

  • The Light Issue

    Issue 174

    The Light Issue

    APR - MAY 2023

  • The Security Issue

    Issue 173

    The Security Issue

    FEB - MAR 2023

  • The Summer Issue

    Issue 172

    The Summer Issue

    DEC 2022 - JAN 2023

  • The Change Issue

    Issue 171

    The Change Issue

    OCT - NOV 2022

  • The E-Issue

    Issue 170

    The E-Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2022

  • The Future Living Issue

    Issue 169

    The Future Living Issue

    JUN - JUL 2022

  • The Transport Issue

    Issue 168

    The Transport Issue

    APR - MAY 2022

  • The Local Issue

    Issue 167

    The Local Issue

    FEB - MAR 2022

  • The Human Issue

    Issue 166

    The Human Issue

    DEC 2021 - JAN 2022

  • The Branding Issue

    Issue 165

    The Branding Issue

    OCT - NOV 2021

  • The Positivity Issue

    Issue 164

    The Positivity Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2021

  • The ‘Not My Fault’ Issue

    Issue 163

    The ‘Not My Fault’ Issue

    JUN - JUL 2021

  • The Fault Issue

    Issue 162

    The Fault Issue

    APR - MAY 2021

  • The Power Issue

    Issue 161

    The Power Issue

    FEB - MAR 2021

  • The Summer Issue

    Issue 160

    The Summer Issue

    DEC 2020 - JAN 2021

  • The Care Issue

    Issue 159

    The Care Issue

    OCT - NOV 2020

  • The Recreation Issue

    Issue 158

    The Recreation Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2020

  • The Recovery Issue

    Issue 157

    The Recovery Issue

    JUN - JUL 2022

  • The Solar Issue

    Issue 156

    The Solar Issue

    APR - MAY 2020

  • The Bigger Business Issue

    Issue 155

    The Bigger Business Issue

    FEB - MAR 2020

  • The Big Business Issue

    Issue 154

    The Big Business Issue

    DEC 2019 - JAN 2020

  • The Elsewhere Issue

    Issue 153

    The Elsewhere Issue

    OCT - NOV 2019

  • The Protection Issue

    Issue 152

    The Protection Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2019

  • The Emissions Issue

    Issue 151

    The Emissions Issue

    JUN - JUL 2019

  • The Retro Fit Issue

    Issue 150

    The Retro Fit Issue

    APR - MAY 2019

  • The Retail and Hospitality Issue

    Issue 149

    The Retail and Hospitality Issue

    FEB - MAR 2019

  • The Bush Issue

    Issue 148

    The Bush Issue

    DEC 2018 - JAN 2019

  • The Training Issue

    Issue 147

    The Training Issue

    OCT - NOV 2018

  • The Connected Home Issue

    Issue 146

    The Connected Home Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2018

  • The Virtual Reality Issue

    Issue 145

    The Virtual Reality Issue

    JUN - JUL 2018

  • The Wiring Devices Issue

    Issue 144

    The Wiring Devices Issue

    APR - MAY 2018

  • The Entertainment Issue

    Issue 143

    The Entertainment Issue

    FEB - MAR 2018

  • The Transport Issue

    Issue 142

    The Transport Issue

    DEC 2016 - JAN 2017

  • The Institution Issue

    Issue 141

    The Institution Issue

    OCT- NOV 2017

  • The Behind the Meter Issue

    Issue 140

    The Behind the Meter Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2017

  • The Winter Issue

    Issue 139

    The Winter Issue

    JUN - JUL 2017

  • The Project Issue

    Issue 138

    The Project Issue

    APR - MAY 2017

  • The Australia Issue

    Issue 137

    The Australia Issue

    FEB - MAR 2017

  • The Disaster Issue

    Issue 136

    The Disaster Issue

    DEC 2016 - JAN 2017

  • The Outdoor Issue

    Issue 135

    The Outdoor Issue

    OCT - NOV 2017

  • The People Issue

    Issue 134

    The People Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2016

  • The Environment Issue

    Issue 133

    The Environment Issue

    JUN - JUL 2016

  • The Safety Issue

    Issue 132

    The Safety Issue

    APR - MAY 2016

  • The Wireless Issue

    Issue 131

    The Wireless Issue

    FEB - MAR 2016

  • The Tools Issue

    Issue 130

    The Tools Issue

    DEC 2015 - JAN 2016

  • The Cable Issue

    Issue 129

    The Cable Issue

    OCT - NOV 2015

  • The LED Issue

    Issue 128

    The LED Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2015

  • The Smart Issue

    Issue 127

    The Smart Issue

    JUN - JUL 2015

  • The ANZAC Issue

    Issue 125

    The ANZAC Issue

    APR - MAY 2015

  • The Australia Issue

    Issue 125

    The Australia Issue

    FEB - MAR 2015

  • The Future Issue

    Issue 124

    The Future Issue

    DEC 2014 - JAN 2015

  • The Renovation Issue

    Issue 123

    The Renovation Issue

    OCT - NOV 2014

  • The Industry Issue

    Issue 122

    The Industry Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2014

  • The Future Shock Issue

    Issue 121

    The Future Shock Issue

    JUN - JUL 2014

  • The Light Issue

    Issue 120

    The Light Issue

    APR - MAY 2014

  • The Green Issue

    Issue 119

    The Green Issue

    FEB - MAR 2014

  • The Press Reset Issue

    Issue 118

    The Press Reset Issue

    DEC 2013 - JAN 2014

  • The Safety Issue

    Issue 117

    The Safety Issue

    OCT - NOV 2013

  • The Business Boot Camp Issue

    Issue 116

    The Business Boot Camp Issue

    AUG - SEPT 2013

The Heritage Issue

Explore Electrical Gems